Attendance policy spurs new debate

Emily Jo Cureton, The Triplicate

At last week's meeting of the Del Norte County Unified School District Board, a handful of local residents - mostly parents, doctors, or both - urged officials to change a policy that lets teens leave class for confidential medical appointments, without the consent of a guardian.

"Confidential services could be seeing a counselor or a psychiatrist, but quite often it's going to a public health clinic seeking information about birth control, contraception and sexual health," Superintendent Don Olson said.

On paper, the district's attendance code is by the book, in line with state law that has withstood multiple legal challenges over the last 30 years.

Teens in California have a constitutionally protected right to consent to their own care and a right to privacy in their reproductive decisions. Much like doctors, public school officials are required to protect that privacy, even from parents.

Opponents of the controversial attendance policy took issue with all

of the above Thursday, while school officials stressed that none of the

above falls to local decision-makers.

After an hour-long discussion, the board unanimously upheld the

current attendance policy, emphasizing the district's preference for

students and parents to schedule medical appointments outside of school


In practice, Del Norte's teens are not entrusting school staff with

confidential medical information in order to miss class. Over the last

five years, only one student is known to have used the policy to leave

campus, Olson said.

"Right now, if students are seeking those services during the day,

they are just cutting class," he added.

The attendance policy came under scrutiny earlier this year, after

the board approved building a teen health clinic on district-owned

property across from Del Norte High School.

"I know it is upsetting to parents, just the fact that your child

could technically excuse themselves from class if they are between the

ages of 12 and 17, to go seek those services. However, I believe we are

bound to follow California Education Code and California law, whether we

are in personal agreement with that or not," Olson said.

He originally supported changing Del Norte's policy to require

parental consent in the event a student wants to leave class, whatever

the reason, but reversed his stance after consulting two attorneys.

Concerned residents, the sheriff and four local physicians spoke

against the policy at the meeting. An eye doctor, two pediatricians and a

retired gynecologist all agreed that practicing sound medicine on

children requires parental involvement.

Some speakers also argued that the education code tramples parental


"If I believed a policy violated parents' rights, I would be willing

as a School Board member to exert leadership," said School Board member

Don McArthur. "As I look at this policy, I don't see that it impairs the

ability of parents to monitor their children in any way. I think

concerned parents have the tools that they need to know the whereabouts

of their children."

Any absence, regardless of the excuse, is recorded and reported

online through the district's new parent-student portal, accessible from

the district's homepage: The site

allows parents to check grades and attendance daily, so long as teachers

keep it updated.

School Board member and parent of a high-schooler Lori Cowan loves

it, she said.

His high-school-aged nephew hates it, Olson said.

Reach Emily Jo Cureton at .

The Del Norte Triplicate
This image is copyrighted.

Crescent City autos, jobs, real estate and merchandise.

Ads appear Online and in Print

View Classifieds

Connect with The Del Norte Triplicate

Triplicate Newsstand

Friday October 21, 2016

Read digital interactive editions of our publications

Read Today's Edition Take A Tour
View All Publications