Del Norte Triplicate Readers

No regrets for celebrating death of a man who rightly deserved it

I have gone to bed the past few nights and awakened each morning with the same thought - why was I celebrating the killing of another human being?

With no reservation or hesitation, I will continue to do so today and the remainder of my life.

I recall over nine a half years ago the footage of the Twin Towers, the Pentagon and a field in Pennsylvania - all exploding and choking in gasps or dust, blood and screaming steel. And the call that came, saying my cousin had died, blown to pieces at the Pentagon. Then the news that 64 people from the county of my birth had also been murdered that day.

And I remember that week, saying on national radio that those people, Osama Bin Laden and his ilk, would never defeat us. Up until last night, Bin Laden's continued existence in some way defied that belief.

Until this last week - when America's best of the best went into

hostile territory and delivered on a promise and vow upheld by two

presidents, two parties and one nation that somehow, someday, justice

would be done.

Given the penchant we have for resorting to athletic metaphors, you

could go to Bobby Fischer in Reykjavik, or Lake Placid in 1980, or Babe

Ruth's called shot in the '32 World Series ... or McArthur returning to

the Philippines, Patton entering Berlin, judgment at Nuremberg and

Hiroshima and every other place this country has stood and delivered.

From the men and women in our armed forces to the firefighters in New

York City and the Pat Tillmans and Bruno de Solennis who saw their duty

and gave the ultimate sacrifice in honoring that commitment, Sunday was

their day as much as anyone's.

I hear talk that Bin Laden wasn't a key player anymore, that Ayman al

Zawahiri is still out there and as Kipling wizened in

"Rikki-Tikki-Tavi," "Baby cobras were hatching down by the river" - as

well as Yemen and the Saudi Peninsula. All irrelevant, because today one

thing above all stands out for me - the man who killed my cousin and

3,500 other innocent Americans is dead because my country never forgot,

never waivered and delivered on its promise to exact justice and I have

never been prouder to be an American.

Jon Alexander

Crescent City

Editor's note: Jon Alexander is district attorney of Del Norte County.

Inappropriate of school authority to urge partisanship in students

I didn't like the May3 Coastal Voices piece ("If we treat our kids

like crops, then we'll pay for schools") by School Board member Don

McArthur. Following is my response:

Politicizing children, Donald McArthur. Would you expect a teacher to

be disciplined for trying to persuade students to join a particular


You evidently urged students to try to persuade "a few Republicans

that kids and schools are worth it." It is not appropriate for a person

in position of school authority to urge adolescents to take a partisan


Bob Buckles

Crescent City

City irresponsible in handling of sewage plant issues like sludge

With some amusement I read the May 4 article about the city mulling

over what to do with the "waste" sludge from our contentious $40

million-plus sewer plant that keeps on costing more every month, it


Now the question is what to do with the sludge left over from the

digestion process at the plant? I am particularly amused that even our

esteemed mayor, and he, an architect no less, sitting on the City

Council; merely noted the physical qualities of our fine sludge; and had

not much else constructive to say about it.

Why not use it, I ask? Many municipalities actually sell the stuff

for its obvious best use, as fertilizer. Some is used in bagged mixed

fertilizer for home usage - much more is hauled or pumped to farmland to

be incorporated for its typically fine soil building and plant feeding


And, too, why are we simply burning off perfectly usable methane from

our sewage plant? The Chinese use theirs to cook with; we might heat a

few public buildings or the pool with ours. As for the issue of fluoride

in our water, it is out of our hands permanently now. Law(s) on the

books state that once a municipality has begun fluoridation of its

potable water, it cannot ever rescind its introduction, not even by vote

(which was illegal).

As for the City Council having purview over the sewage plant; that

shouldn't be either. There should be an entirely separate district, none

of its members sitting on any city boards or the council.

We live in an odd, rather backwards-thinking community. Arcata did a

fine job for its citizenry, about 15,000 at last count, with its clever

ponding of secondary treated effluent; the City of Santee, Calif., does

the same. Both are models for recreation and wise use of resources at


Have we lands for water impoundments of a marsh sort? I recall one

angry citizen who suggested we follow Arcata's example. Nope. Had to

have a biomembrane plant, its only use thus far to flood the sands of

our beachfront city park.

But, now, who pays for every need of that white elephant, time and

time again? As a non-city person unable to even vote for our City

Council members, I'd surely invite them to all find other jobs. Perhaps

the sewage plant?

Hilary John Herman

Crescent City

Congress ignores plight of those with cancer - please help them

In March, the U.S. House of Representatives passed a bill that would

cut funding to cancer research by 5.2 percent of its $268 billion

budget. Sadly, many Americans who have been touched by this vile disease

are unaware of this devastating loss.

Well-known cancer survivors, such as Tour de France winner Lance

Armstrong, are taking the fight to Congress, urging them to reconsider.

In a press conference in Washington, Mr. Armstrong summed up the

importance of this research quite concisely with "600,000 deaths a year

... that's 1,500 American lives a day."

With so many lives at stake, the American public should be aware of

this drastic cut. But you don't have to be an internationally known

athlete to combat this cut. There are organizations such as the American

Cancer Society that work hard to pass bills on the state and federal

levels that increase the taxes on items such as cigarettes in order to

contribute funding to cancer research and awareness.

As citizens of the United States, we have all been witness to the

horrors of cancer. It is in our town, it is in our cities, it is in our

media and it is in our homes. It is important for American citizens to

know what is in store for their friends and family who have been touched

by cancer, and as a graduate of Del Norte High School, I want to share

this news with the citizens of my hometown who have aided in the fight

against cancer for many years with the Relay for Life every July.

Ours is a community that cares deeply for its friends and family, and

my article will show them what is happening with the war against cancer

that they all take such an important role in. Having lost my

grandfather to lung cancer, it is my wish to raise cancer awareness in

my community.

Wesley Hale


Special thank you to lady who returned purse found outside

A special thank you to the sweet lady who returned my purse to

Grocery Outlet on Tuesday, May 3, after finding it outside in a grocery


You cannot believe my joy upon reclaiming it. Thank you so much. God

bless you!

Heather Isdell

Crescent City