Coastal Voices: Resighini stand on dam removal

Triplicate Staff

The Resighini Rancheria is a small federally recognized tribe with a reservation at the top of the Klamath River estuary.

We are of Yurok ancestry. Our people have fished the Klamath River since time immemorial and we remain dependent on the bounty of the river, both for our sustenance and our spiritual well being.

The Resighini Rancheria favors removal of four Klamath Hydroelectric Project (KHP) dams, but strongly opposes the implementation of the Klamath Basin Restoration Agreement (KBRA) that is part of the government dam removal process.

Our tribal government was denied participation in the Klamath

Settlement talks, but we have studied the issues while participating in

review of government dam removal environmental documents. We have come

to the conclusion that our treaty rights and the government's trust

responsibility should not be changed to favor politically powerful farm

interests as part of dam removal.

Also, dam owner PacifiCorp should be made to remove its polluting

dams sooner than 2020 and replace its power generating capacity at the

expense of its rate-payers, not at the expense of the citizens of

California.

The Indian people of the Klamath River Basin share a harmony-based

culture where all living creatures are part of a living river system.

The Upper Klamath ecosystem historically provided clean water for the

Lower Klamath River, until the Klamath Project reduced lakes and

wetlands by 80 percent.

By preventing recovery of the marshes and shallow lakes of the Upper

Klamath Basin, the Klamath Settlement will block the recovery of water

quality as well as the endangered sucker fish and dozens of bird species

dependent on the Tule Lake and Lower Klamath National Wildlife Refuges.

During our government-to-government meetings, we asked that the

effects of the KBRA be scientifically analyzed. Government

representatives declined, saying that its effects were unknown and yet

to be determined.

In fact the KBRA and its effects are already being felt. In January

2012 the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation turned off the water to the refuges

and in March 2012, dead ducks started falling from the sky. From

October 2011 through February 2012, Lower Klamath River flows were drawn

down to levels that violated the coho salmon Biological Opinion for

Klamath Project operation and created potential risk of increasing algae

blooms that are known to be a major factor in salmon disease epidemics.

In April 2010, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service allowed the bureau

to draw down Tule Lake to levels that would not support Lost River and

shortnose suckers, and to capture the fish and transport them to Upper

Klamath Lake. We have asked U.S. Secretary of the Interior Ken Salazar

to explain why these agencies are not upholding the Endangered Species

Act, but he has not responded.

The federal legislation to authorize dam removal is stalled and

likely dead. California has made no indication that it will come up with

the $250 million required for dam removal under the Klamath Settlement.

The Resighini Rancheria agrees with the Hoopa Tribe that dam removal

through the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) relicensing

process will be the quickest path to decommissioning. Although FERC

staff recommended dam retention for power generation, the requirement by

the National Marine Fisheries Service for fish ladders that cost $240

million will render the project uneconomic. This forces dam

decommissioning at PacifiCorp's expense and would involve a simple

settlement not involving water rights or tribal trust, similar to the

one the company recently signed to facilitate removal of the Condit Dam

in Washington state.

The California State Water Resources Control Board has the ability to

block relicensing of the KHP because the reservoirs within the project

create thermal, nutrient and toxic algae pollution. Interim measures

that PacifiCorp is following until 2020 under the Klamath Settlement do

not lessen these conditions.

On Tuesday, we will attend the Water Board's meeting and call upon it

to assert its authority, recognized in both the Clean Water Act and the

Federal Power Act, and to re-activate its 401 Certification process.

The Resighini Rancheria hopes that citizens of the North Coast will

make their voices heard to get dams removed through the FERC process and

to work for Klamath River ecological restoration that truly restores

Harmony to the basin.

See www.KlamathER.org for more information.

Donald McCovey is the chairman of the Resighini Rancheria Tribal

Council

14030658
The Del Norte Triplicate
This image is copyrighted.

Crescent City autos, jobs, real estate and merchandise.

Ads appear Online and in Print

View Classifieds

Connect with The Del Norte Triplicate


Triplicate Newsstand

Thursday August 25, 2016

Read digital interactive editions of our publications

Read Today's Edition Take A Tour
View All Publications